Foreign players never guessed played MLS and surprising careers

Foreign players never guessed played MLS is a fascinating topic that highlights how many world-class icons finished their careers in North America without much global fanfare. If you look back at the historical databases on soccerwayuk, you will find surprising names ranging from European legends to South American masters who briefly graced the pitch in the United States. 

10 Legendary Foreign Players You Never Guessed Played in MLS

Over the decades, several iconic foreign players never guessed played MLS long enough to leave a lasting legacy on the pitch. From Ballon d'Or winners to Premier League centurions, the league has hosted some of the most recognizable faces in football history. Here is soccerwayuk.com concise look at 10 superstars who traded the glitz and glamour of Europe for the burgeoning ambitions of American soccer.

10. Kaká - Orlando City

The Brazilian magician arrived in Florida as Orlando's first Designated Player after a legendary career at AC Milan and Real Madrid. He quickly justified his record-breaking salary by scoring a stunning free-kick equalizer during his debut match in 2015. Despite battling recurring injuries in his final season, the Ballon d'Or winner remained a fan favorite until 2017. 

Kaká had a glorious career, winning the UEFA Champions League

9. Kieran Gibbs - Inter Miami

The former Arsenal left-back made a surprising transition to the South Beach club in 2021 after leaving West Bromwich Albion. He brought immense Premier League experience to a young Inter Miami squad looking to establish its identity. In early 2023, Gibbs mutually agreed to terminate his playing contract to pursue a different passion.

8. Nani - Orlando City

Nani brought his trademark flair and Manchester United pedigree to Orlando City in 2019, instantly becoming a focal point of their attack. He famously led the club to the finals of the 2020 MLS is Back Tournament with several clutch performances. The Portuguese winger’s tenure was marked by spectacular goals and a strong work ethic that inspired his teammates. 

7. Teemu Pukki - Minnesota United

Known as a Norwich City legend, Pukki shocked many fans by signing with Minnesota United as a Designated Player in 2023. He made history by becoming the first player in franchise history to score four goals in a single match. By early 2025, the Finnish international decided to return home to join his former club, HJK Helsinki.

6. Steven Gerrard - LA Galaxy

The Liverpool icon made headlines in 2015 when he signed an 18-month deal to join the star-studded LA Galaxy. He debuted with a goal and an assist, briefly reuniting with his former international teammate Robbie Keane. While Gerrard struggled with the heavy travel demands of the United States, his presence significantly boosted the league's global profile. 

Steven Gerrard is one of Liverpool FC’s greatest legends of all time

5. Alessandro Nesta - CF Montréal

Widely considered one of the greatest defenders ever, Nesta moved to Montreal in 2012 after a trophy-laden decade at AC Milan. He provided a defensive masterclass during his short stint, helping the club secure the 2013 Canadian Championship. The Italian veteran brought an unmatched level of elegance and tactical intelligence to the North American backline. 

4. Ashley Cole - LA Galaxy

After winning every major trophy in England, Ashley Cole joined the Galaxy in 2016 to solidify their defense. He proved he still possessed elite quality, eventually being named the team's captain for the 2018 season. Despite a few disciplinary red cards, his leadership was vital during a transitional period for the Los Angeles club. 

3. Bojan Krkić - CF Montréal

Once hailed as the "next Messi" at Barcelona, Bojan brought his technical brilliance to Montreal in 2019. He famously scored a breathtaking 25-yard strike against Toronto FC shortly after his arrival in the league. Then, Bojan soon departed for Japan, continuing his unique journey through the world’s top leagues.

2. Tim Cahill - New York Red Bulls

The Australian legend joined the Red Bulls in 2012, bringing his famous headed-goal prowess to the New York skyline. He set an incredible MLS record by scoring just eight seconds into a match against Houston in 2013. Cahill was instrumental in the club's pursuit of silverware and became a massive personality within the league. 

Tim Cahill is a well-known Australian football legend

1. Jermain Defoe - Toronto FC

In 2014, Toronto FC famously utilized the help of rapper Drake to convince the English striker to move to Canada. Defoe started his MLS career explosively, netting two goals in a memorable debut victory over the Seattle Sounders. Among the foreign players never guessed played MLS, Defoe’s stay was perhaps the most turbulent due to management changes. He returned to the Premier League in 2015, but his brief time in Toronto remains a significant moment in the club's history.

Top 10 foreign players never guessed played MLS:

Jermain Defoe 

Tim Cahill 

Bojan Krkić 

Ashley Cole

Alessandro Nesta

Steven Gerrard 

Teemu Pukki 

Nani 

Kieran Gibbs 

Kaká 

Foreign players never guessed played MLS highlights the rich, often overlooked history of international talent in the United States. For more deep dives into football history and the latest updates on your favorite leagues, be sure to check out the news section of our website.